Breed: Deutsch Drahthaar, German Wirehaired Pointer
Posted: Tue Apr 08, 2008 12:02 am Post subject:
munstyman wrote:
WOW ,
So be nice to Peter ( me) and and put details of the various tests here and lets discuss them, and there strengths and weaknesses, not the kennels.
Peter
Thanks for the plea ..... I will try again
How about I just give you all a description of the finished dog test (VGP) and some pretty pics to look at. We can then happily rip apart the tests one at a time ....... sound fun
Here is a link to the description of one of the VGP tests that I was at as a guest observer judge:
Sorry kiwi, I'm still not certain you've read the scheme itself, its at the top of the page in `announcements'. Apologies if you have and I'm mis reading your post, its just that there are NO comments within the scheme itself. It comes as a pdf document just to make it clear.
Peter
yes i have read it, i might send a link to our own nzvhda it might be of some use to you, pretty simple in design and designed off the navhda model...but i think margaret was helped by the griffon club.
Posted: Tue Apr 08, 2008 8:37 am Post subject: Re: Requested Field Trial Awards
Mike wrote:
maxine mccullough wrote:
As requested here is a list of our Field Trial Awards
Hi Maxine,
Thank you for that.
Mike
Hi Mike,
As I have been insulted publicly on here by Windum Bang and with very some very nasty private mails, told by you yesterday that his requests were not unreasonable and to answer his question, would you be so good as to to answer my question now please - is this a requirement for everyone to do this????
I asked if Sharon could do the same as she claims the Undisputed Top winning UK GWP kennel - your comments were made as I claimed to be the top winning UK DD kennel - (Sorry Sharon this is not a dig at you) - however the unsavory notes from Windum Bang were totally unnecessary, I just wonder why Sharon has never fallen foul of his tongue, clearly someone is working him from the sidelines
Maybe we could also have a comprehensive list from Mr Windum Bang too just for comparison.
Thanks
Maxine _________________ Maxine McCullough
Kimmax
The UK's undisputed top Deutsch Drahthaar kennel
I don't see that you have been insulted on here by Bill at all Maxine. All he has done is question your claims.
Please don't cause arguments on this forum the way you have done on so many others. This is a lovely friendly place to chat about working hpr's and yet every thread you have got involved in has been turned into a war.
I pm'd the moderators yesterday as I am concerned that your persecution complex and subsequent temper tantrums will lead to people feeling unable to post their opinions which would effectively kill the forum. None of us want that to happen.
I've only looked at this thread twice now, once last night & just now. Admittedly I haven't seen all the thread but what I am seeing I don't like
From where I am sitting I am seeing 2 GWP kennels sniping at each other which I don't think this is the place to do it. Each kennel has/is successful in their own right and of course both have gone about this in their own ways.
Personally I think you should rise above any comments from anyone and just get on with whatever disciplines you choose with your dogs & enjoy your dogs. _________________ Claire Minstergate Weimaraners
I will back what both Claires have said. This has until now been a place I have felt confident and able to express my opinions and experiences and have never been made to feel unqualified or unwelcome. The unpleasantness expressed in this thread and others on the subject of GWP/DDs recently has really shocked me.
I don't wish to point fingers but it was not difficult for me to sense the etiquette when I joined this, my first, forum. Gentle or not so gentle digs were always taken and dealt out with good humour until now and apologies generously given and accepted. It seems somebody or bodies have completely misinterpreted the purpose of this forum or alternatively have come on here with the intention of picking a fight. What the hell happened?
I couldn't agree more Claire and Claire! I've given up trying to learn anything from this thread after my original plea was immediately thanked and then in the same posting the snide remarks continued Nae point flogging a dead horse so I'm off to enjoy the rest of this forum because thankfully the vast majority of posters are friendly and helpful both on and off the forum. Phew! _________________ Hunting is natural, even foxes do it !
Whenever life hands you lemons, grab the salt and add the tequila
I will back what both Claires have said. This has until now been a place I have felt confident and able to express my opinions and experiences and have never been made to feel unqualified or unwelcome. The unpleasantness expressed in this thread and others on the subject of GWP/DDs recently has really shocked me.
I don't wish to point fingers but it was not difficult for me to sense the etiquette when I joined this, my first, forum. Gentle or not so gentle digs were always taken and dealt out with good humour until now and apologies generously given and accepted. It seems somebody or bodies have completely misinterpreted the purpose of this forum or alternatively have come on here with the intention of picking a fight. What the hell happened?
Helen S
Hi Helen,
Yes I agree it is totally ridiculous however as you have seen we have been persecuted regarding our dogs where we have brought our dogs from, accused of not having won any awards with them and requested by both Mr Windum Bang and Mike to supply a list of achievements, which I thought was totally out of order but supplied anyway. I haven't seen anyone else had the same request thrown at them.
I will certainly be glad to see it stopped however I wasn't the cause of it as you can clearly see.
Regards,
Maxine
_________________ Maxine McCullough
Kimmax
The UK's undisputed top Deutsch Drahthaar kennel
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum